Tripod Advisors Tripod Advisors
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Schlesinger’s Thoughts
  • 关于
2012 Sep.11

China and the Transparency Gap

David SchlesingerBusiness, China, Media, Uncategorized

Rumors and Chinese politics are nothing new.

 

In fact, my memories of my four years as Reuters Beijing bureau chief in the 1990s are filled with frustrating days and nights trying to track down some intriguing/important/insane/incomprehensible rumor about political change, leaders’ health, diplomatic machination or fundamental shift in the landscape.

 

Some turned out to be true. Most turned out not to be.

 

Plus ça change plus c’est la même chose!

 

The air in China, polluted at the best of times, is now thick with the fug of rumors about president-to-be Xi Jinping and why he’s not been seen recently.

 

The NYT has a good round up 

 

Some may turn out to be true; some won’t.

 

The big difference now is that China has a transparency gap. With hundreds of millions of users on line using microblogs and millions more sending sms messages over their phones, the feeling of urgency is greater than ever. The noise is overwhelming.

 

And, of course, China is much more of a world player than ever before – while China may still see itself as a developing country, the world looks at it as a major power and expects the same standards of openness as it would about the health of an American president.

 

Good luck getting that!

 

“We have told everybody everything,” said the foreign ministry spokesman. That’s clearly not true; what is true is that he may have told everybody everything that the foreign ministry knows. The black box that is the leadership means “need to know” extends to a very small number of people indeed.

 

That leads me to some of the lessons I learned as a foreign correspondent:

 

  • Occam’s razor holds true.  Don’t ignore the straightforward explanation; don’t rush to the most complex theory.
  • Those who speak usually don’t know; those who know don’t speak.
  • Those who speak, even if they know, have an agenda
  • The level of noise has nothing to do with the level of truth
  • Don’t expect China to play by other places’ rules

 

Do any of these rules help understand what’s really going on? Unfortunately no. But maybe they can help us avoid taking a severe wrong turn.

CHINAMEDIA
Share this:
  • Previous

    If you liked the chat, you’ll love the talk….

  • Next

    And there he is!

Latest in Schlesinger’s Thoughts

  • Can the G7 Compete with Belt and Road?
  • Chinese Jets, Taiwanese Angst, American Statements
  • China’s Covid Lockdowns – Testing Times
  • Xi, Putin and Ukraine
  • China 2021 GDP Growth – Phew!

Categories

  • Asia
  • Business
  • China
  • Media
  • Portfolio
  • Speeches
  • Uncategorized

Tags

AGENCY BUSINESS BUSINESS CHINA CHINA CHINAFILE CHINAFILE CPJ DAVID SCHLESINGER DAVID SCHLESINGER diplomacy Economy EXPERIENCE FOREIGN REPORTING FOREIGN REPORTING FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION HONG KONG HONG KONG HUMAN RIGHTS INFORMATION INFORMATION JOURNALISM JOURNALISM LEADERSHIP MEDIA MEDIA Military North Korea PRESS FREEDOM PRESS FREEDOM Protests REUTERS Russia SOCIAL MEDIA SOFT POWER SPEECHES Taiwan Trade TRIPOD ADVISORS Trump U.S. United States Xi Jinping XINJIANG

Archives

  • June 2022  2
  • April 2022  1
  • March 2022  1
  • January 2022  1
  • December 2021  1
  • November 2021  1
  • October 2021  1
  • September 2021  2
  • July 2021  1
  • June 2021  2
  • May 2021  1
  • July 2020  2
  • April 2020  1
  • March 2020  2
  • January 2020  1
  • December 2019  2
  • October 2019  2
  • September 2019  1
  • August 2019  2
  • July 2019  1
  • June 2019  2
  • March 2019  4
  • February 2019  1
  • January 2019  2
  • December 2018  1
  • November 2018  2
  • September 2018  1
  • August 2018  5
  • July 2018  2
  • June 2018  2
  • May 2018  3
  • April 2018  2
  • August 2017  3
  • June 2017  1
  • May 2017  1
  • March 2017  1
  • February 2017  1
  • November 2016  2
  • September 2016  2
  • July 2016  1
  • June 2016  1
  • March 2016  1
  • February 2016  2
  • December 2015  2
  • November 2015  1
  • October 2015  1
  • September 2015  1
  • August 2015  3
  • July 2015  3
  • April 2015  1
  • February 2015  1
  • January 2015  3
  • October 2014  2
  • September 2014  1
  • July 2014  2
  • June 2014  1
  • March 2014  2
  • February 2014  1
  • January 2014  1
  • October 2013  3
  • September 2013  1
  • July 2013  2
  • May 2013  3
  • March 2013  5
  • February 2013  1
  • January 2013  1
  • November 2012  2
  • October 2012  1
  • September 2012  3
  • August 2012  1
  • July 2012  1
© 2016 Tripod Advisors. D. A. Schlesinger Limited. Designed by iPulse Design Ltd.